No Perfection
Five years (and a bit) ago, when my wife and I took over here at Allan, my uncle Nicholas Gray shared with us that when he just couldn’t seem to find a Bible to suit someone, he’d say both to them, and reassuringly to himself, ‘Don’t forget – there will be no perfection this side of heaven.’ As far as I can see this phrase dates back to the American theologian William Cogswell’s book ‘The Christian Philanthropist’, published in 1839 – though Google will show up plenty of quotes in sermons from around the world.
There has been some heated discussion on social media recently about what one should expect from a premium Bible. Obviously we want every customer to be happy with their Bible when they receive it – and if they’re not, they can always return it for a full refund and with no restocking fee. Should there be a defect with the Bible we will also cover the return postage too (and don’t forget we offer free shipping worldwide when purchasing).
But at the same time – and particularly with a first-time customer – we will make a real effort to engage with what they’re seeing, and although photos can be misleading, particularly with natural materials and flexible fine Bibles bindings, we will do our best to review with the customer what’s going on and, if we don’t think what they’re seeing is a problem, we will endeavour to explain in full what might be happening.
What can be particularly hard to convey – and for people to get their heads around – is that we have made key strategic decisions that make consistency and total accuracy harder, not easier. We want our Bibles to have unparalleled flexibility in the binding, fully taking advantage of the strength offered by Smyth sewn binding and leather-lined case-making. So we use the finest Bible papers and natural grain leathers. This brings many benefits, but means, for example, that getting the book block to stay rounded can be genuinely challenging for the bindery; we could add reinforcing material behind the book block, but that would compromise the overall flexibility.
We only use natural grain goatskin and calfskin leathers, and that means that the texture of the surface can vary significantly between Bibles, or even on the same Bible, depending on which part of the hide was used. It means that there may be insect bites or thorn scars on the skin which are visible on the finished product. It also means that the leather may not pleat consistently around the corners of the case, because the leather has varying levels of stiffness at each corner; or with the liner leather (and we are the only publisher all of whose full-size Bibles are lined with real leather), it may mean that the leather folds a little awkwardly down the edge of the spine inside, which may mean that the book block sits ever so slightly off square. However, again because these are natural materials, the appearance of all these features will change over time as the Bible is used. It really depends on you whether you’ll see this as a good thing or a bad one, but it’s what we and our most loyal customers love about the Allan Binding style!
Then again, we want the deepest colour of red under gold for our art gilt page edges, and that means that there will always be some appearance of red under the foil around the edge of each page, and when the paper takes slightly differently this will spread into inconsistent bleed.
Jongbloed
The plain fact is that our Bibles are different to almost any other available today. So when we say ‘We know that the Allan binding style doesn’t suit everyone’, we’re not being patronising: it’s the plain truth. Some people don’t like our Bibles. And that’s fine.
If you don’t like how our Bibles come out, though, there’s a simple solution: don’t buy them.
What I think is tough for people is when they have heard the hype (not from us) that Allan Bibles are ‘perfect’ and ‘incomparable’ – and then they get their Bible, and they just can’t see it. Their idea of perfect is about millimetre precision or 32nds-of-an-inch exactitude, rather than the smell of natural leather and the glister of red-under-gold. We’ve just had to accept that for those folks our Bibles will probably never match up.
But that’s OK, because there’s a world of other options out there, from a $2.50 economy Bible up to $100 plus ‘genuine leather’ Bibles, all of which offer a significantly more precise machine-made option. Then again, Schuyler and Cambridge University Press offer great quality Bibles with a high degree of hand-work involved. We are so blessed to have such a multitude of fantastic options to choose from in the English-speaking world.
Over the past few years we have fulfilled thousands of customer orders and dealt with a fair few queries and complaints along the way, and the simple truth is that everyone’s mileage varies. Some people get an Allan Bible out of the box and love it from the first moment – others get the ruler out and start measuring tolerances. Of course, sometimes there are genuine problems with the Bible, and most people fall somewhere between the extremes. But if you know you’re the ruler type, maybe our Bibles aren’t for you!